Pizza, ice cream, white bread, cookies and potato chips now make up most of the American food supply. According to a debate published in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, that shift may have less to do with willpower than with how these foods are made.

Ashley Gearhardt of the University of Michigan argues that highly processed (HP) foods behave a lot like addictive substances. Opiates, cocaine and tobacco all start as natural plants and are processed into products with unnaturally high concentrations of a reinforcing ingredient. HP foods, she says, follow the same recipe. Manufacturers combine refined carbohydrates and fat, often with sodium and additives, at levels far beyond anything found in fruit, vegetables or legumes.

Built to be reinforcing

Addiction isn’t a single chemical mark, Gearhardt notes. It’s characterized by behavior: loss of control in consuming, intense cravings, persisting despite negative effects, repeated unsuccessful attempts to reduce. Her research indicates that HP foods, but not minimally processed foods, are all related to these four.

The foods most associated with these patterns are those that combine carbohydrates with fat, like chocolate, ice cream, fries and pizza. Sugary cereals, gummy candy and white bread count too – they’re refined carbohydrates, which raise blood sugar rapidly. Bacon and steak, which are high in fat and low in carbs, had less addictive potential. So, it’s not just food in general, and the paper doesn’t say that butter and plain chicken are addictive. It is aimed at manufactured goods.

Industry processing aggravates it, Gearhardt writes. Elimination of fiber increases the rate of sugar and starch delivery. Sodium boosts the reward value of sweet and fatty foods. Familiar foods are enhanced with flavorings and texturizers in the factory versions that aren’t used in their home-made equivalents. Cigarette manufacturers did the same and added substances that allowed for the easier absorption of nicotine.

Who gets hooked

Not all of those people who eat these foods lose control, and most of those who attempt cocaine don’t become addicted (approximately 21%). Researchers estimate that approximately 15% of individuals would qualify for a diagnosis of HP, which is nearly the same prevalence as alcohol use disorder (AUD) (14%). The risk factors are also shared: trauma history, mood disorders, impulsivity and eating in response to negative emotions.

Early signs of tolerance AND withdrawal. In one study, brain activity in a reward area decreased following frequent sweetened beverages, while others have become irritated and depressed when they reduce their intake of HP foods.

The industry parallel

Gearhardt is straight out of Big Tobacco’s camp. Tobacco’s addictiveness was long denied, in part because cigarettes don’t give a “high.” This allowed businesses to increase the addictive qualities of their products and to target children without much regulation. She mentions the same thing occurred with OxyContin, which minimized the risk of addiction and blamed the addict. If HP foods were classified as non-addictive, she says, food companies would continue as they are creating new products, peddling them to kids, and blaming eating too much on the individual. She also points to studies that indicate that those who perceive such foods as “addictive” are more favorable towards initiatives on taxing and restricting marketing to children.

The other side

There is a counter argument to the debate, and it is one of which readers ought to be aware. The evidence, however, does not stand up, says Co-author Johannes Hebebrand at the University of Duisburg-Essen. He says there is no particular addictive ingredient. HP foods are not intoxicating or “high” producing and are probably not as rewarding as traditional drugs. Only 5% of 1,495 young adults reported food addiction to sugar-sweetened foods in a Dutch study, and the energy density seemed to be a more important factor than addiction.

The vast majority of obese individuals do not exhibit the characteristics of food addiction and the majority of non-obese individuals do. The label may contribute to stigma, warns Hebebrand. Despite this, he believes that the food industry has succeeded very well in developing products that are not easily resisted and that regulation is needed, including restrictions on the marketing of foods to children and on HP foods in schools.

The format is important, too. According to the journal, this series is “Oxford-style debate” and the participants must argue “positions” that they have been given and the opinions expressed do not necessarily represent those of the participants.

What it means

There is one thing both sides agree on: A food environment where cheap, heavily marketed, hyper-rewarding foods abound is bad for the human appetite. Gearhardt’s argument is that if it is called addiction, that is a stronger case, and to make companies responsible as well as the consumer.

Punit Panchal is a content writer who specializes in clear, engaging, and SEO-friendly pieces that simplify complex topics. From emerging technologies to product insights, Punit focuses on delivering value-driven content that connects with readers and ranks effectively.

HEgoogleNews